论兴奋剂管制中的未成年人权利保护
The Protection of Minor's Rights in Doping Control
投稿时间:2024-07-22  
DOI:10.12064/ssr.2024072203
中文关键词:兴奋剂管制  反兴奋剂  未成年人  权利保护
英文关键词:doping control  anti-doping  minors  rights protection
基金项目:国家社会科学基金项目(23BTY036)
作者单位
彭梦桐 北京新华印刷有限公司北京 100000 
摘要点击次数: 0
全文下载次数: 5
中文摘要:
      2021年版《世界反兴奋剂条例》引入了受保护人员概念,旨在降低违规未成年人的举证责任,并对其实施更为宽缓的制裁措施。通过分析瓦利耶娃案可知,在2027年版《世界反兴奋剂条例》出台前,现有规则在保护未成年人方面的效果并不显著,未成年人从证明责任和处罚措施的特别规定中受益难度较大,其违规信息的非强制公开披露也很难得到保证。为了平衡公平纯洁赛事的要求与未成年人这一特殊主体的利益,进一步完善兴奋剂管制中对未成年人的保护,建议:其一,遵循未成年人权利保护的底层逻辑,保证儿童最大利益原则与比例原则在“立法”与“司法”中的应用,同时重视反兴奋剂教育工作,预防和矫治兴奋剂违规行为;其二,减轻未成年人兴奋剂违规的证明负担、非故意证明负担,并将主观过错证明责任转移至反兴奋剂机构;其三,增加未成年人强制性临时停赛的豁免情形;其四,保障未成年人兴奋剂违规信息的非强制公开披露规则的落实。
英文摘要:
      The 2021 version of the WADC introduces the concept of protected persons, which imposes lighter sanctions on them. Analysing the Valieva case, it is clear that prior to the 2027 edition of WADC, the effectiveness of the existing rules is limited, that it is difficult for minors to benefit from the special provisions on burden of proof and sanctions, and that non-mandatory public disclosure of information about their violations is difficult to ensure. Balancing the requirements of a fair and clean event with the interests of the special subject of minors, improving the protection of minors in doping control can start from the following aspects. Firstly, follow the underlying logic of minors' rights protection, ensure that the principle of the best interests of the child and the principle of proportionality are applied in 'legislation' and 'justice', and at the same time, pay attention to anti-doping education, so as to play a preventive and corrective role in doping violations; Secondly, to reduce the burden of proving doping offences for minors, both in terms of reducing the burden of proving inadvertence and shifting the burden of proving subjective fault to anti-doping organisations; Thirdly, to increase the number of exemptions from mandatory Provisional Suspensions for minors; Fourthly, to guarantee the implementation of the rule of non-compulsory public disclosure of information on minors' doping violations.
查看全文  查看/发表评论  下载PDF阅读器
关闭